Winter 2004 Volume 26
Insurance and Rising Construction Costs Feature Articles:
“Commercial and industrial building costs have increased substantially over the past year,” explains Snethen. He also notes that technological advancements in valuation programs can now provide more accurate reconstruction costs to help owners insure to value. “As a result of these two factors, building owners can expect to see increases of 15 to 30 percent in building valuations.”
It Costs More To Build Today Than It Did A Year Ago
According to a recent survey published in Engineering Record News (ENR), just about every material used in the construction process has increased in price since 2003.
- Reinforcing bar is up 41 percent over 2003 prices.
- Structural steel is up 24 percent.
- Lumber is up 27 percent.
- Stainless steel shelving and plate products are up 22 and 26 percent respectively.
According to ENR, there is no sign that prices will decrease in the coming year.
“The cost of building materials is only one factor in rising building costs,” notes Snethen. “The fuel needed to process and transport many of these materials is up 33 percent.” Snethen points out that the increase in labor wages is another factor in rising building costs. “Many facilities have also added expensive security systems since 2001, which has driven up reconstruction costs.”
Is Your Insurance Keeping Up With Rising Construction Costs?
Even if your building is less than a year-old, you have to be prepared to answer the question — Do I have adequate insurance protection in the event of a total or partial loss? According to recent studies, 73 percent of commercial policyholders are under-insured by almost 40 percent. To help building owners insure to value, EMC recently made some improvements to its commercial cost estimating program. According to Snethen, the new program, BVS-Commercial, developed by Marshall & Swift/Boeckh, provides owners with accurate reconstruction costs. “Unlike traditional replacement cost values, reconstruction costs represent the cost at current prices to rebuild a damaged or destroyed building using like kind and quality of materials, construction standards, design and workmanship,” explains Snethen. “Although reconstruction costs tend to be greater than new construction, they are a much better representation of insurance value.”
New Estimating System Provides A Truer Picture Of Reconstruction Costs
BVS-Commercial offers several advantages over other systems.
- Accurate reconstruction costs — BVS-Commercial contains data for all major construction specification items, allowing us to price the cost to build a structure from the ground up, incorporating all the local wage and material costs needed for that specific location.
- Flexibility for a wide variety of building types and occupancies — BVS-Commercial incorporates hundreds of building occupancies, six construction types, the latest building codes, and the ability to include specific materials.
- Credibility — Marshall & Swift/Boeckh is recognized as the premier provider of insurance building cost information and estimating systems in the country.
- Easy to understand — BVS-Commercial reports not only have more details, but are easy to read and understand.
We Don’t Want Anyone To Be Surprised — Now Or Later!
Although some owners may be surprised by increases in valuations resulting from rising costs and the shift to “reconstruction” costs, it is a much less frightening surprise than learning you are not insured to value at the time of a loss.
We encourage you to talk to your EMC agent about your building values. Don’t wait for your renewal to make certain your insurance is keeping up with the rising construction costs. Call today and avoid being surprised!
To maintain worker safety during maintenance of rooftop equipment, managers should consider these suggestions in developing a safety plan:
- Make certain a power disconnect is within eyesight of equipment served.
- Install guard rails and platforms where regular maintenance is required but cannot be performed while standing on the roof.
- Mark trip hazards — such as expansion joints, vents and pipes — that cross the roof.
- Build walkways over trip hazards in areas of consistent foot traffic to allow for easier movement of workers, materials and tools.
- Provide adequate lighting around rooftop equipment.
From bricks to wire and cable, the cost of just about every component used in the construction industry has risen dramatically over the past year. Check out these recent figures from ENR and you’ll quickly understand why reconstruction costs are increasing.
|Pipe & Pipe Fitting||+26.0%|
|Wire & Cable||+12.9%|
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1.4 million injuries and illnesses that required recuperation away from work occurred in private industry in 2002. Sprains and strains were the leading cause of injury in every major industry.
What occupations tend to report the highest number of injuries?
- Truck drivers
- Nursing aides, orderlies and attendants
- Laborers (nonconstruction)
- Janitors and cleaners
- Construction laborers
- Supervisors, proprietors, salespeople
- Sales clerks
By implementing loss control programs, even the most dangerous jobs can become less hazardous.
Every year, The Hartford Steam Boiler Inspection and Insurance Co. (HSB) investigates numerous boiler failures. The primary reasons for these failures are poor or non-existent water treatment and little or no preventive maintenance for the boilers. We are pleased to share some of HSB’s safety guidelines with the readers of Loss Control Insights.
- Monitor Start-Up: Don’t expect to fire the boiler at the beginning of the heating season and then walk away for days or weeks. The probability of something happening to the boiler is highest during the start-up period.
- Water Treatment: Water treatment to control corrosion is a must for all low-pressure steel boilers. If you have a cast-iron boiler, it is important to use pure water and to keep the system as tight as possible. The only way to determine the quality of the water used in your system is by sampling and testing. Once an analysis is made, a plan of action can be developed to properly treat your boiler water.
- Leakage: Preventive maintenance, including periodic inspection of the system to detect leakage, must be performed. Corrective action can be taken before minor leakage becomes a major boiler repair.
For more information about water treatment and maintenance for your low-pressure boiler, visit www.hsb.com.
In 2003, there were more than 73,000 snow shoveling-related injuries treated at hospital emergency rooms, doctor’s offices and clinics. What can you do to reduce the risk of injury? Here are some tips from the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.
- Check with your doctor — Shoveling places high stress on your heart so be sure your body can handle it.
- Pace yourself — Take frequent breaks and replenish fluids to prevent dehydration.
- Shovel early and often — Begin when a light covering of snow is on the ground.
- Look before you load — Watch out for large rocks, branches, ice patches and uneven surfaces.
- The right tool — Use a shovel that feels comfortable for your height and strength.
- Lift carefully — It is always best to push the snow, but if you have to lift, do it properly. Squat with your legs apart, knees bent and back straight. Lift with your legs, without bending at the waist. Do not throw snow over your shoulder or to the side.
Partnership Service is EMC’s unique and extremely effective process which focuses on developing cost-effective, practical and operational changes to reduce losses.
A task force, made up of your own employees, works closely with an EMC consultant to identify work-related tasks that have the potential for serious injury or loss. The task force then develops cost-effective ideas to reduce or eliminate exposure to these tasks. This process typically results in effective changes to your operations and less employee resistance to the changes because your own employees developed the ideas.
The process is designed to:
- Identify and prioritize potential problems.
- Develop solutions.
- Propose changes in operations to eliminate potential hazards.
- Focus on developing cost effective, practical solutions.
Count on EMC and your local EMC agent to provide your organization with proven ways to reduce workplace losses.
A worker tries to ignore the tingling or numbness she has had for months in her hand and wrist. Suddenly, a sharp, piercing pain shoots through the wrist and up her arm. Just a passing cramp? More likely she has carpal tunnel syndrome, a painful progressive condition caused by compression of a key nerve in the wrist.
In a recent study, an estimated three of every 10,000 workers lost time from work because of carpal tunnel syndrome. The average lifetime cost of carpal tunnel syndrome, including medical bills and lost time from work, is estimated to be about $300,000 for each injured worker.
The Mayo Clinic offers the following precautions workers can take to protect their hands and avoid injury.
- Ease up: Most people use more force than necessary to perform many tasks involving the hands. Type lightly. Use a big pen with free-flowing ink for prolonged handwriting. That way, you won’t have to grip as tightly or press hard.
- Take frequent breaks: Every 15 or 20 minutes, give your hands a break by stretching or moving them. If you use equipment that vibrates or requires force, taking breaks is even more important.
- Watch your form: Avoid bending your wrist all the way up or down.
- Improve your posture: Incorrect posture can cause your shoulders to roll forward, shortening your neck and shoulder muscles and compressing nerves in your neck. This can affect your wrists, fingers and hands.
- Keep your hands warm: You’re more likely to develop hand pain and stiffness if your fingers are cold. If you can’t control the temperature, try wearing fingerless gloves.
You can learn more about carpal tunnel syndrome — what it is, how to diagnose it, how to treat it and how to prevent it — by visiting EMC’s Web site at www.emcinsurance.com or the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke at www.ninds.nih.gov.
Motor vehicle mechanics and spray paint applicators are being cautioned about the highly-reactive chemical known as isocyanates. This chemical, which can severely affect the human respiratory system, is widely used in foam manufacturing, automobile spray paints, truck bed coatings, commercial polyurethane products and the auto repair industry.
The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) warns that isocyanates are powerful irritants to the eyes and respiratory tracts. They can also sensitize workers, making them subject to severe asthma attacks if they are exposed again. Asthmatic attacks may occur immediately or may be delayed for up to 12 hours after exposure, so symptoms may occur away from work. Fatal cases have been reported, but these are rare.
Early symptoms that may result from exposure to isocyanates include sore eyes, runny nose, sore throat, coughing, wheezing or tight chest, and breathlessness.
NIOSH says preventing exposure to isocyanates is a critical step in eliminating the hazard. Adequate control when isocyanate paints are used may be achieved by segregating spraying operations from other activities in a booth or enclosure. Vapors and sprays are then ventilated to a safe place in the open air after adequate filtration. People inside the booth should wear appropriate respiratory equipment. Compressed air breathing apparatus incorporating a full face mask or visor is normally used. The booth should be thoroughly inspected on a regular basis to ensure that enclosure and ventilation are effective. Respiratory equipment should also be checked regularly.
[This information provided courtesy of Safety Smart.]
What items are most likely to disappear from the shelves of grocery and convenience stores? Here’s the top ten most frequently shoplifted items according to the Food Marketing Institute:
- Advil tablet, 50 ct.
- Advil tablet, 100 ct.
- Aleve caplet, 100 ct.
- EPT pregnancy test (single)
- Gillette Sensor, 10 ct.
- Kodak 200, 24 exp.
- Similac with iron powder (case)
- Similac with iron powder (can)
- Primatene tablet, 24 ct.
- Sudafed caplet, 24 ct.
LICENSE ENDORSEMENT FOR DRIVERS OF 15-PASSENGER VANS
As a result of several recent fatal accidents, The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is recommending that all states establish a driver’s license endorsement for 15-passenger vans. The endorsement would require drivers to complete a training program and pass a written and skills test. NTSB is also recommending that the definition of buses and commercial motor vehicles apply consistently to 12- and 15-passenger vans.
HIRING SAFE DRIVERS
A new rule from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration requires employers to review all applicant’s professional driving safety records and requires former employers to make that information available.
THE “VALUE” OF PERSONAL PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT
The International Safety Equipment Association has published a brochure entitled “Personal Protective Equipment: An Investment In Your Workers’ and Company’s Future.” Order copies by calling 703-525-1695.
The Engineering News Record (ENR) recently reported that equipment theft could be costing contractors one billion dollars a year. Worse yet, as little as 10 to 15 percent of stolen equipment is ever recovered.
The high value of heavy equipment and the difficulty of securing machines and worksites make equipment an attractive target for thieves. The costs of replacing stolen equipment, short-term rentals and business interruption directly affect your productivity and profitability. The National Equipment Register offers the following loss prevention and security techniques for equipment owners.
- Conduct announced and random worksite visits to ensure nothing unusual is occurring while work is not in progress.
- Consider hiring a guard service to monitor your worksite and/or installing video surveillance systems. If you cannot afford this, ask other local businesses about sharing resources.
- Maintain a list of employees authorized to enter/leave your worksite and which people may use specified pieces of equipment.
- Keep a detailed and accurate inventory of all equipment on a given worksite, including year, manufacturer, model number and PIN or serial number. Photos are also strongly recommended.
- Register equipment on a national database that works with law enforcement.
- Customize equipment with unique paint colors, such as painting the roof a distinctive color or painting the unit number in large characters.
- Post warning signs indicating the penalties imposed for stealing equipment. Signs should also note that all equipment have their serial numbers recorded and on a national database.
- Use see-through fencing material, at least eight-feet high with posts spaced at a distance no greater than the width of the narrowest unit in your fleet.
For a comprehensive list of loss prevention and security techniques visit www.enr.com or contact your EMC loss control specialist.
Construction is a risky business throughout the world. In Europe, for example, nearly 13 workers per 100,000 are killed in construction-related accidents. Many of these occur at small construction sites. That is why the European Agency for Safety and Health (EASH) recently published a fact sheet on health and safety at small construction sites.
We encourage you to use the following checklist developed for European Week for Safety and Health At Work as a starting point to look for common dangers on small construction sites.
|YES ____||NO____||Are dangerous substances on site being properly stored and used?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are suitable protective measures being used to prevent or reduce exposure to dust (for example, wood, cement, silica)?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are workers wearing proper head protection and footwear?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are workers using the right personal protective equipment for the job?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are appropriate safety signs in place?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are adequate fire precautions in place?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are existing power lines (buried and overhead) identified?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are the vehicle operators properly trained?|
|YES ____||NO____||Have the lifts and hoists been properly installed and checked by competent people?|
|YES ____||NO____||Is the condition of scaffolding checked periodically and after adverse weather?|
|YES ____||NO____||Is material delivered in manageable sizes and weights to reduce the risk of back injury?|
|YES ____||NO____||Have workers been instructed on how to lift safely?|
|YES ____||NO____||Is fall protection used everywhere it is required?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are holes protected with clearly marked and fixed covers to prevent falls?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are measures in place to reduce exposure to noise and vibration?|
|YES ____||NO____||Are there safer ways to do a job other than using a ladder?|
Rare is the organization where roofing funds flow like water; almost every building owner has the quandary of too many problem roofs for the money available. The problem may well be a lack of money, but it could also be lack of a coherent roof management plan.
EMC Insurance Companies partners with Benchmark, Inc., a nationally-recognized roofing consulting firm, to assist clients in the development of roof management plans. Jeff Evans, RRC, from Benchmark, offers the following advice to business owners. Most maintenance and engineering managers of commercial and institutional facilities agree in theory, that regular inspections are an essential part of a roof management program. They would also recognize and agree with the basic roof management tenet that regular roof inspections and routine maintenance reduce ownership costs, reduce leak frequency and severity, extend roof life, and reduce management inefficiencies.
In practice, we have found that by the time many organizations think about starting a roof management plan, they are in need of a roof replacement program. Why in practice then, don’t most organizations have a viable roof inspection and maintenance plan? Is it inertia, a “we’ve never done it that way before” mentality, a fear of the unknown? What is certain, is that most plans never get started. Also certain, is that even a minimal plan is better than no plan. The best advice is to just get started!
Step 1: Take Inventory
This inventory begins with developing a historical file for each roof that includes these bits of information about each roof: date of installation; installing contractor; system manufacturer; warranties; type of membrane; insulation and roof deck; leak history; and repair history, dates, type and cost of repairs.
Step 2: Roof Assessment
No roof can be appropriately managed without first knowing the roof’s history and then understanding the current condition of the roof. Current roof condition is obtained by conducting roof inspections. Whether surveys are done by in-house staff or contracted to a consultant depends on the technical competence and availability of your resources.
The roof survey should include: examination of roof membrane, flashings, sheet metal flashings, drains, gutters, etc; evaluation of observed conditions that may impact the long-term performance of the roof system; documentation of deficiencies requiring corrective action; and development of long-range preventive maintenance needs.
Step 3: Formulate a Plan
The information gathered does no good if it sits on a shelf accumulating dust. The data needs to be recorded and studied, as it will help identify the opportunities to make repairs, conduct maintenance or anticipate reroofing.
Don’t be one of the facility managers whose roofs have to be replaced before their design lives are reached, or for whom emergency repairs are needed at the least opportune time. Don’t let your good roofs sit neglected, doomed to early failure. The solution begins with a well-devised roof inspection and maintenance plan. So get started!
Roadway crashes continue to be the leading cause of work-related fatalities for workers in the United States. Although other workplace fatalities have declined in recent years, the number of deaths from roadway crashes have remained steady. Prevention of work-related roadway crashes poses one of the greatest challenges in occupational safety.
The roadway is a unique work environment. Compared with other work settings, the employer’s ability to control working conditions and to exert direct supervisory controls is limited. Traffic volumes and road construction continue to increase. Workers may be pressured to drive faster and for longer periods and to use technologies that may lead to inattention to the driving task. The problem of work-related roadway crashes affects those who occasionally drive passenger vehicles on the job as well as those who routinely drive commercial motor vehicles over long distances.
Despite these challenges, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) recommends a proactive employer policy to promote vehicle safety on and off the job. Here are some NIOSH recommendations you can put into effect to reduce work-related crashes.
- Provide vehicles that offer the highest levels of occupant protection in the event of a crash and ensure that these vehicles receive regular inspection and maintenance.
- Check driving records of drivers, ensure that workers have valid driver’s licenses, and provide appropriate training for the vehicle the worker will operate.
- Do not place drivers at risk by pressing them to complete deliveries or client contacts within unrealistic time frames.
- Implement and enforce the mandatory use of seat belts. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration estimated that in 2002, the use of seat belts prevented 10,347 fatalities in the United States!
- Comply with Federal Motor Carriers Safety Administration regulations regarding the number of hours commercial motor vehicle operators can drive in a given day.
- Limit, as much as possible, the use of cell phones and other in-vehicle technologies that may distract drivers from their primary function.
- Assign driving-related tasks to young drivers in an incremental fashion, beginning with limited driving responsibilities and expanding responsibilities as they gain experience.
What more can you do to reduce work-related crashes? Keep informed. Watch for more information in upcoming issues of Loss Control Insights, check out the loss control pages at www.emcinsurance.com, and visit NIOSH's Web site at www.cdc.gov/niosh.
Murphy’s law — “Anything that can go wrong will go wrong” — did not apply to the middle and senior high school in Boone, IA on September 23, 2004. Other than the normal problems, the school day wasn’t much different than any other day. Then a student decided to add some excitement by starting a fire in the second floor boy’s bathroom.
Fortunately, the school had emergency procedures and systems in place to handle the situation. These included: a fire sprinkler system, a smoke detection system, an emergency evacuation plan, an emergency notification plan, and fire extinguisher training program. An observant and quick-thinking freshman, on her way to class, smelled smoke and noticed it coming from the bathroom. She immediately went to the nearest room (as instructed in the emergency notification plan) and reported what she observed. A member of the janitorial staff was in the room and quickly headed to the bathroom to assess the situation. By this time, the smoke activated the smoke detection system, and the school was evacuated (according to the emergency evacuation plan) in an orderly fashion.
Being trained in the proper use of a fire extinguisher and aware of the location of the closest fire extinguisher, the janitor was able to initially knock down the flames. Then a properly designed fire sprinkler system kept the fire under control and contained within the bathroom until the fire department arrived. Firefighters finished putting the fire out and used fans to push the smoke out of the bathroom window. In the end, what may have resulted in a catastrophic loss was reduced to minor fire and water damage, confined to the bathroom.
Without having every one of the multiple plans and systems that were involved in this incident in place and operational, this minor fire could have resulted in far more damage to the building and possibly injury to students and staff. If you don’t have all of these emergency plans and systems in place, contact your EMC agent to schedule a visit from an EMC loss control professional who can make sure your buildings, staff, and students have what it takes to help, prevent, or reduce unnecessary losses from fires.
With parents and community leaders demanding better protection in the classroom, electronic security and surveillance systems are becoming widespread in schools. As your school district invests in this costly technology, it adds to your equipment breakdown risks and building values. According to a guide prepared for the National Institute of Justice, the total cost of school security systems can run into tens of thousands of dollars. So if you have this type of equipment in your school, or are thinking about installing it, check with your EMC agent to make certain your valuation includes these additional costs.